Reedle Откройте в мобильном приложении
Понятно
Понятно
Для того чтобы воспользоваться закладками, необходимо
Войти или зарегистрироваться
Отмена
Для того чтобы воспользоваться озвучкой предложений, необходимо
Войти или зарегистрироваться
Отмена
Озвучка предложений доступна при наличии PRO-доступа
Купить PRO-доступ
Отмена
"
Now
when
was
the
real
time
of
the
crime
?
And
who
killed
him
?
"
In
my
opinion
,
and
this
is
only
an
opinion
,
Ratchett
was
killed
at
some
time
very
close
upon
two
o'clock
,
the
latest
hour
the
doctor
gives
us
as
possible
.
"
As
to
who
killed
him
--
"
Отключить рекламу
He
paused
,
looking
at
his
audience
.
He
could
not
complain
of
any
lack
of
attention
.
Every
eye
was
fixed
upon
him
.
In
the
stillness
you
could
have
heard
a
pin
drop
.
He
went
on
slowly
:
"
I
was
particularly
struck
by
the
extraordinary
difficulty
of
proving
a
case
against
any
one
person
on
the
train
and
on
the
rather
curious
coincidence
that
in
each
case
the
testimony
giving
an
alibi
came
from
what
I
might
describe
as
an
'
unlikely
'
person
.
Thus
Mr.
MacQueen
and
Colonel
Arbuthnot
provided
alibis
for
each
other
--
two
persons
between
whom
it
seemed
most
unlikely
there
should
be
any
prior
acquaintanceship
.
The
same
thing
happened
with
the
English
valet
and
the
Italian
,
with
the
Swedish
lady
and
the
English
girl
.
I
said
to
myself
,
'
This
is
extraordinary
--
they
can
not
all
be
in
it
!
'
"
And
then
,
Messieurs
,
I
saw
light
.
They
were
all
in
it
.
For
so
many
people
connected
with
the
Armstrong
case
to
be
travelling
by
the
same
train
by
a
coincidence
was
not
only
unlikely
,
it
was
impossible
.
It
must
be
not
chance
,
but
design
.
I
remembered
a
remark
of
Colonel
Arbuthnot
's
about
trial
by
jury
.
A
jury
is
composed
of
twelve
people
--
there
were
twelve
passengers
--
Ratchett
was
stabbed
twelve
times
.
And
the
thing
that
had
worried
me
all
along
--
the
extraordinary
crowd
travelling
in
the
Stamboul
--
Calais
coach
at
a
slack
time
of
year
was
explained
.
Отключить рекламу
"
Ratchett
had
escaped
justice
in
America
.
There
was
no
question
as
to
his
guilt
.
I
visualized
a
self-appointed
jury
of
twelve
people
who
condemned
him
to
death
and
were
forced
by
exigencies
of
the
case
to
be
their
own
executioners
.
And
immediately
,
on
that
assumption
,
the
whole
case
fell
into
beautiful
shining
order
.
"
I
saw
it
as
a
perfect
mosaic
,
each
person
playing
his
or
her
allotted
part
.
It
was
so
arranged
that
if
suspicion
should
fall
on
any
one
person
,
the
evidence
of
one
or
more
of
the
others
would
clear
the
accused
person
and
confuse
the
issue
.
Hardman
's
evidence
was
necessary
in
case
some
outsider
should
be
suspected
of
the
crime
and
be
unable
to
prove
an
alibi
.
The
passengers
in
the
Stamboul
carriage
were
in
no
danger
.
Every
minute
detail
of
their
evidence
was
worked
out
beforehand
.
The
whole
thing
was
a
very
cleverly-planned
jig-saw
puzzle
,
so
arranged
that
every
fresh
piece
of
knowledge
that
came
to
light
made
the
solution
of
the
whole
more
difficult
.
As
my
friend
M.
Bouc
remarked
,
the
case
seemed
fantastically
impossible
!
That
was
exactly
the
impression
intended
to
be
conveyed
.
"
Did
this
solution
explain
everything
?
Yes
,
it
did
.
The
nature
of
the
wounds
--
each
inflicted
by
a
different
person
.
The
artificial
threatening
letters
--
artificial
since
they
were
unreal
,
written
only
to
be
produced
as
evidence
.
(
Doubtless
there
were
real
letters
,
warning
Ratchett
of
his
fate
,
which
MacQueen
destroyed
,
substituting
for
them
these
others
.