Reedle Откройте в мобильном приложении
Понятно
Понятно
Для того чтобы воспользоваться закладками, необходимо
Войти или зарегистрироваться
Отмена
Для того чтобы воспользоваться озвучкой предложений, необходимо
Войти или зарегистрироваться
Отмена
Озвучка предложений доступна при наличии PRO-доступа
Купить PRO-доступ
Отмена
"
Now
we
come
to
the
evidence
of
Mr.
Hardman
.
I
believed
all
that
he
told
me
about
his
own
identity
,
but
when
it
came
to
the
actual
methods
he
had
employed
to
guard
Mr.
Ratchett
,
his
story
was
neither
more
nor
less
than
absurd
.
The
only
way
effectively
to
have
protected
Ratchett
was
to
have
passed
the
night
actually
in
his
compartment
or
in
some
spot
where
he
could
watch
the
door
.
The
only
thing
that
his
evidence
did
show
plainly
was
that
no
one
in
any
other
part
of
the
train
could
possibly
have
murdered
Ratchett
.
It
drew
a
clear
circle
round
the
Stamboul-Calais
carriage
.
That
seemed
to
me
a
rather
curious
and
inexplicable
fact
,
and
I
put
it
aside
to
think
over
.
"
You
probably
have
all
heard
by
now
of
the
few
words
I
overheard
between
Miss
Debenham
and
Colonel
Arbuthnot
.
The
interesting
thing
to
my
mind
was
the
fact
that
Colonel
Arbuthnot
called
her
Mary
and
was
clearly
on
terms
of
intimacy
with
her
.
But
the
Colonel
was
only
supposed
to
have
met
her
a
few
days
previously
--
and
I
know
Englishmen
of
the
Colonel
's
type
.
Even
if
he
had
fallen
in
love
with
the
young
lady
at
first
sight
,
he
would
have
advanced
slowly
and
with
decorum
--
not
rushing
things
.
Therefore
I
concluded
that
Colonel
Arbuthnot
and
Miss
Debenham
were
in
reality
well
acquainted
,
and
were
for
some
reason
pretending
to
be
strangers
.
Another
small
point
was
Miss
Debenham
's
easy
familiarity
with
the
term
'
long
distance
'
for
a
telephone
call
.
Yet
Miss
Debenham
had
told
me
that
she
had
never
been
in
the
States
.
Отключить рекламу
"
To
pass
to
another
witness
.
Mrs.
Hubbard
had
told
us
that
lying
in
bed
she
was
unable
to
see
whether
the
communicating
door
was
bolted
or
not
,
and
so
asked
Miss
Ohlsson
to
see
for
her
.
Now
,
though
her
statement
would
have
been
perfectly
true
if
she
had
been
occupying
compartments
Nos.
2
,
4
,
12
,
or
any
even
number
--
where
the
bolt
is
directly
under
the
handle
of
the
door
--
in
the
uneven
numbers
,
such
as
compartment
No.
3
,
the
bolt
is
well
above
the
handle
and
could
not
therefore
be
masked
by
the
sponge
bag
in
the
least
.
I
was
forced
to
the
conclusion
that
Mrs.
Hubbard
was
inventing
an
incident
that
had
never
occurred
.
"
And
here
let
me
say
just
a
word
or
two
about
times
.
To
my
mind
,
the
really
interesting
point
about
the
dented
watch
was
the
place
where
it
was
found
--
in
Ratchett
's
pyjama
pocket
,
a
singularly
uncomfortable
and
unlikely
place
to
keep
one
's
watch
,
especially
as
there
is
a
watch
'
hook
'
provided
just
by
the
head
of
the
bed
.
I
felt
sure
,
therefore
,
that
the
watch
had
been
deliberately
placed
in
the
pocket
and
faked
.
The
crime
,
then
,
was
not
committed
at
a
quarter
past
one
.
"
Was
it
,
then
,
committed
earlier
?
To
be
exact
,
at
twenty-three
minutes
to
one
?
My
friend
M.
Bouc
advanced
as
an
argument
in
favour
of
it
the
loud
cry
which
awoke
me
from
sleep
.
But
if
Ratchett
were
heavily
drugged
he
could
not
have
cried
out
.
If
he
had
been
capable
of
crying
out
he
would
have
been
capable
of
making
some
kind
of
a
struggle
to
defend
himself
,
and
there
were
no
signs
of
any
such
struggle
.
Отключить рекламу
"
I
remembered
that
MacQueen
had
called
attention
,
not
once
but
twice
(
and
the
second
time
in
a
very
blatant
manner
)
,
to
the
fact
that
Ratchett
could
speak
no
French
.
I
came
to
the
conclusion
that
the
whole
business
at
twenty-three
minutes
to
one
was
a
comedy
played
for
my
benefit
!
Anyone
might
see
through
the
watch
business
--
it
is
a
common
enough
device
in
detective
stories
.
They
assumed
that
I
should
see
through
it
and
that
,
pluming
myself
on
my
own
cleverness
,
I
would
go
on
to
assume
that
since
Ratchett
spoke
no
French
the
voice
I
heard
at
twenty-three
minutes
to
one
could
not
be
his
,
and
that
Ratchett
must
be
already
dead
.
But
I
am
convinced
that
at
twenty-three
minutes
to
one
Ratchett
was
still
lying
in
his
drugged
sleep
.
"
But
the
device
has
succeeded
!
I
have
opened
my
door
and
looked
out
.
I
have
actually
heard
the
French
phrase
used
.
If
I
am
so
unbelievably
dense
as
not
to
realize
the
significance
of
that
phrase
,
it
must
be
brought
to
my
attention
.
If
necessary
MacQueen
can
come
right
out
in
the
open
.
He
can
say
,
'
Excuse
me
,
M.
Poirot
,
that
ca
n't
have
been
Mr.
Ratchett
speaking
.
He
ca
n't
speak
French
.
'