Reedle Откройте в мобильном приложении
Понятно
Понятно
Для того чтобы воспользоваться закладками, необходимо
Войти или зарегистрироваться
Отмена
Для того чтобы воспользоваться озвучкой предложений, необходимо
Войти или зарегистрироваться
Отмена
Озвучка предложений доступна при наличии PRO-доступа
Купить PRO-доступ
Отмена
"
Then
the
matter
is
easy
to
follow
,
"
responded
the
psychologist
,
dryly
.
"
If
Mr.
Byerley
breaks
any
of
those
three
rules
,
he
is
not
a
robot
.
Unfortunately
,
this
procedure
works
in
only
one
direction
.
If
he
lives
up
to
the
rules
,
it
proves
nothing
one
way
or
the
other
.
"
Quinn
raised
polite
eyebrows
,
"
Why
not
,
doctor
?
"
"
Because
,
if
you
stop
to
think
of
it
,
the
three
Rules
of
Robotics
are
the
essential
guiding
principles
of
a
good
many
of
the
world
's
ethical
systems
.
Of
course
,
every
human
being
is
supposed
to
have
the
instinct
of
self-preservation
.
That
's
Rule
Three
to
a
robot
.
Also
every
'
good
'
human
being
,
with
a
social
conscience
and
a
sense
of
responsibility
,
is
supposed
to
defer
to
proper
authority
;
to
listen
to
his
doctor
,
his
boss
,
his
government
,
his
psychiatrist
,
his
fellow
man
;
to
obey
laws
,
to
follow
rules
,
to
conform
to
custom
--
even
when
they
interfere
with
his
comfort
or
his
safety
.
Отключить рекламу
That
's
Rule
Two
to
a
robot
.
Also
,
every
'
good
'
human
being
is
supposed
to
love
others
as
himself
,
protect
his
fellow
man
,
risk
his
life
to
save
another
.
That
's
Rule
One
to
a
robot
.
To
put
it
simply
--
if
Byerley
follows
all
the
Rules
of
Robotics
,
he
may
be
a
robot
,
and
may
simply
be
a
very
good
man
.
"
"
But
,
"
said
Quinn
,
"
you
're
telling
me
that
you
can
never
prove
him
a
robot
.
"
"
I
may
be
able
to
prove
him
not
a
robot
"
"
That
's
not
the
proof
I
want
.
"
Отключить рекламу
"
You
'll
have
such
proof
as
exists
.
You
are
the
only
one
responsible
for
your
own
wants
.
"
Here
Lanning
's
mind
leaped
suddenly
to
the
sting
of
an
idea
,
"
Has
it
occurred
to
anyone
,
"
he
ground
out
,
"
that
district
attorney
is
a
rather
strange
occupation
for
a
robot
?
The
prosecution
of
human
beings
--
sentencing
them
to
death
--
bringing
about
their
infinite
harm
-
"
Quinn
grew
suddenly
keen
,
"
No
,
you
ca
n't
get
out
of
it
that
way
.
Being
district
attorney
does
n't
make
him
human
.
Do
n't
you
know
his
record
?
Do
n't
you
know
that
he
boasts
that
he
has
never
prosecuted
an
innocent
man
;
that
there
are
scores
of
people
left
untried
because
the
evidence
against
them
did
n't
satisfy
him
,
even
though
he
could
probably
have
argued
a
jury
into
atomizing
them
?
That
happens
to
be
so
.
"